anal training
Prostate Play Sex Ed
7 min read

Anal Training: How to Size Up Without Wrecking Your Progress

By Alex Men’s Wellness Writer

At a Glance

  • It's conditioning, not stretching: you're teaching a muscle to relax on command, not permanently widening anything.
  • Consistency beats intensity: 15 to 20 minutes, three or four times a week, does more than one long punishing session.
  • Size up in small steps: quarter-inch increases, and only after the current size is genuinely easy.
  • Expect weeks to months, depending on where you're starting and how often you practise.
  • Pushing too fast costs you more time than going slow: a tear or a bad session can set you back weeks.

The phrase anal training makes it sound like a gym programme with a target weight. It's closer to learning to relax a muscle you've spent your whole life keeping shut.

The anal sphincter has two rings. The outer one you control, but the inner one is involuntary, and it responds to relaxation rather than instruction. Everything below is about teaching the involuntary half to stand down, which takes repetition and patience rather than force.

Training Versus Stretching

Anal stretching is the term most people search for, and it's slightly misleading. You aren't stretching tissue out permanently. Muscle that's forced past its capacity doesn't stay obligingly open; it tears, then heals tighter and more guarded than before.

What actually changes with practice is the reflex. The sphincter learns that pressure isn't a threat, so it stops clamping down automatically. Circulation to the area improves. You develop a sense of what relaxed feels like from the inside, which is the skill that carries over to everything else.

How to Relax Anal Muscles

This is the core skill, and it's worth practising on its own before any toy is involved.

Breathe out on the pressure. The pelvic floor releases on the exhale and tightens on the inhale. Time every insertion with a slow breath out, and half the difficulty disappears.

Bear down slightly. The same gentle push as a bowel movement opens the outer ring. It feels counterintuitive when something's going in, and it works.

Warm up externally first. A few minutes of external massage around the opening brings blood to the area and signals that nothing's under attack. And, if you're using a vibrating butt plug, try stimulating the external area with those vibrations before going in.

Get properly warm. A hot shower or bath beforehand does more for muscle tension than any technique on this list.

If you're tensing your jaw, shoulders, or fists, your pelvic floor is tense too. They travel together. Unclench everything above the waist and the rest follows. 

A Realistic Anal Training Routine

A workable anal training routine looks like this:

  • Warm up. Shower, then five minutes of external massage and a lubed finger.
  • Insert your current size. Slowly, on an exhale, with far more lube than feels necessary.
  • Sit with it. 15 to 20 minutes. Stay relaxed and breathe normally rather than clenching around it.
  • Remove slowly. Bear down, steady pressure, no yanking.
  • Rest a day. Tissue recovers between sessions, not during them.

Three or four sessions a week is the sweet spot. Daily offers no advantage and removes the recovery that makes the practice work. If you're sore going into a session, skip it.

Butt plug training is the most common approach because a plug stays put without your hands, letting you relax properly instead of holding something in position.

How to Progress Butt Plug Sizes

The rule that prevents most setbacks: only size up when your current plug goes in easily, sits comfortably for 20 minutes, and comes out without effort. All three, consistently, across several sessions.

Then move up by roughly a quarter inch in width. Not half an inch, and certainly not to whatever's next in the box.

A few things people get wrong when working out how to progress butt plug sizes:

  • Changing size and material at once. Steel at 1.25 inches feels far bigger than a silicone butt plug at 1.25 inches, because there's no give. Change one variable per step. Our guide to butt plug materials covers how much the feel differs.
  • Measuring by length. Width is the only dimension that matters here.
  • Treating a good day as the new baseline. One easy session doesn't mean you've arrived. Repeat it before you move on.

Progress isn't linear either. Stress, tiredness, and dehydration all make a session harder. A bad week isn't lost ground.

How Long Does Anal Training Take?

Honestly: weeks to months, and it depends on where you're starting.

Going from nothing to a comfortable inch takes most people two to four weeks of consistent practice. Getting from there to 1.5 inches often takes a couple of months. Beyond that, progress slows considerably, and plenty of people stop when they reach a size that suits what they enjoy, which is a perfectly good place to finish.

The variable that matters most is frequency, not session length. Twenty minutes four times a week beats two hours on a Sunday, every time.

Do You Need an Anal Training Set?

An anal training set gives you three or four graduated sizes in one purchase, which is an efficient approach.

Buying individually costs more per plug and less overall, because each one is a size you've earned and will actually use. However, we would advise against buying large kits that go from XXS to XXL. Let's be real, you'll probably end up using only the middle three sizes.

Signs You're Moving Too Fast

Stop and drop back a size if you notice any of these:

  • Sharp or burning pain at any point, rather than pressure,
  • Any bleeding, even slight,
  • Soreness that's still there the next day,
  • Needing to force the widest point through,
  • Dreading the session.

That last one is worth taking as seriously as the physical signs. Anal training that's become a chore has usually turned into something you're pushing through rather than enjoying, and that's when injuries happen.

Dropping back a size isn't failure. Two weeks at a smaller size beats six weeks recovering from a tear.

Technique Still Matters

No amount of training compensates for rushing the basics. Lube generously and reapply, warm up every time regardless of how far along you are, and go slowly on removal as well as insertion. Our walkthrough on how to use a butt plug covers positioning and wear time in detail.

If you're starting from scratch, the size you begin with sets up everything that follows, and our guide to picking a beginner anal plug will keep you from buying something you can't use yet.

What You're Training For

Worth asking at some point: what's the destination?

For some people it's comfortable receptive sex. For others it's accommodating larger toys. And for plenty of men, the size was never the goal at all; the prostate was, in which case a curved massager will get you there faster than a bigger plug will. Our comparison of butt plug vs prostate massager lays out which tool suits which goal.

Training goes better with a plug you can leave in comfortably and forget about, which is what GIDDI's butt plugs are made for.

Use the Vulcan vibrating prostate plug as a target rather than a starting point. Its wearable shape, built-in cock and scrotum rings, and wireless remote give you somewhere to go once the size stops being the interesting part.

Where This Leads

Once you're relaxed and comfortable, the interesting part starts. GIDDI's prostate massagers are built for what comes after the training: Tomo adds a wireless remote to the come-hither motion, while Thor brings a 360-degree rotating head for anyone who's worked up to something girthier. Medical-grade silicone, waterproof, 30-day satisfaction guarantee.

Give Your Prostate Wings.

Related Reading